A comparative guide on the best materials for functional but stylish kitchen cabinets

There are various types of kitchen cabinet materials available in New Zealand, each offering unique benefits to enhance your kitchen's aesthetic and functionality. Choices range from solid wood to stainless steel, each adding its own dynamic to the kitchen space. Deciding the right materials for your cabinet panels will take some time and consideration. However, a basic understanding of the different materials can simplify the process and ensure that you make the right decision for your kitchen.

Solid wood cabinets are crafted from whole wood pieces creating a natural and timeless appeal. They come in a variety of wood species, including kauri, matai, jarrah, and oak, each bringing its own grain patterns and colours, making its finish unique to your kitchen.

Advantages:

Durability, aesthetic appeal, and sound absorption: Cabinets made of solid wood are quite durable and have a long lifespan, often exceeding 50 years. Moreover, the different types of wood and grain patterns can enhance their aesthetic appeal. For instance, kauri offers a straight grain complemented with natural lustre, as opposed to jarrah, which typically comes in an interlocked or wavy grain with a medium texture. Looks aside, solid wood has natural sound-absorbing qualities that can reduce noise in a busy kitchen.

Disadvantages:

Prone to warping: Despite their reputation for being durable, solid wood cabinet materials are prone to humidity, which can cause them to warp and crack.

Ideal home:

Those who want to prioritise durability with a time-tested look of natural beauty will enjoy having solid wood cabinets in their kitchen. Their sound absorption, durability and aesthetic make it a great choice for homes with busy kitchens.

Pro tip:

Ensure the wood is properly treated and sealed to prevent warping and moisture damage. Consider the type of wood for its durability and aesthetic qualities, such as oak for strength or cherry for a rich appearance. Keep your budget in mind with the need for high-quality craftsmanship, as solid wood is an investment that adds significant value and timeless appeal to your kitchen.

Melamine is a synthetic material made by pressing a paper or fabric base soaked in melamine resin onto a core of particleboard or MDF. This material is then subjected to heat and pressure to create a durable surface.

Advantages:

Pest-resistant, affordable and stylish: An interesting feature of melamine cabinets is that its resin component is resistant to termites and other pests. Also, this type of material is usually more affordable than other types so it’s an economically friendly option for budget-conscious home buyers. Additionally, cabinets made with this type of material are durable and can resist humidity and moisture damage.

Disadvantages:

Impact damage and weight: Although these types of cabinets are resistant to humidity and moisture if they are not sealed properly, they become sensitive to moisture damage. Also, they are heavier compared to other materials, which can make installation a bit of a challenge.

Ideal home:

Melamine kitchen cabinets offer a sleek modern design with the added ability to mimic more expensive materials making it a cost-effective choice without sacrificing style. These types of cabinets are great for budget-friendly and busy households that require low-maintenance solutions. 

Pro tip:

Take advantage of their durability and wide range of available colours and finishes, which can suit various design preferences while being budget-friendly. Ensure that edges are properly sealed to prevent moisture infiltration, and opt for high-quality melamine to minimise the risk of chipping or peeling over time.

Medium-density fibreboard is an engineered wood product that is made through the process of breaking down hard or softwood residuals into wood fibres. These fibres are then combined with wax and a resin binder and formed into panels by applying high temperature and pressure.

Advantages:

Smooth surface and cost-effective: A smooth surface is ideal for painting, allowing the homeowner easy customisation options and ensuring a high quality. An added benefit of this cabinet material is that it's typically more affordable than other materials.

Disadvantages:

Moisture sensitivity and less strength: If not sealed properly, MDF can swell, making it unsuitable for humid areas. Furthermore, while MDF is generally strong, it can crack and split under heavy loads.

Ideal home: 

MDF is regarded for its customisation and smooth finish, which allows the homeowner to make the cabinet their own. This is perfect for homeowners who want a polished look. MDF cabinets do best in indoor environments where moisture levels are kept low to prevent swelling and warping.

Pro tip:

When painting your MDF cabinets, be sure to use a primer before you paint to ensure a smooth, even finish. The primer helps the paint adhere and prevents the MDF from absorbing too much paint, leading to an uneven surface.

Veneer cabinets consist of thin slices of real wood glued onto a substrate like MDF, particleboard, or plywood. This method offers the natural look and feel of the natural wood grain with the stability and cost-effectiveness of engineered wood substrates.

Advantages:

Cost-effective appeal and environmentally friendly: It provides a real wood appearance at a lower cost by using thin slices of high-quality wood, causing fewer trees to be used to make the kitchen cabinet material. This results in both a budget-friendly and environmentally-friendly option.

Disadvantages:

Brittle and hard to repair: Vaneer cabinets are susceptible to chipping, peeling, and scratching and are ultimately less durable than other materials. Additionally, repairs can be costly since special tools and skills are needed to retain the colour and grain pattern during the repair.

Ideal home:

Veneer brings the look and warmth of natural wood but at a cost-effective price. These qualities make this material ideal for modern or contemporary design styles. Furthermore, homes that prioritise eco-friendliness will enjoy this knowing that veneer maximises the use of wood resources making it more sustainable than solid wood.

Pro tip:

To help maintain your veneer, it’s important to promptly repair minor chips and scratches. Doing so will prevent the damage from getting worse. Using wood filler or touch-up kits can effectively fix these small imperfections and keep your veneer looking its best.

Laminate cabinets are made by fusing multiple layers of resin-soaked paper or fabric to a substrate under high heat and pressure. The resulting surface is durable and can mimic a variety of materials, including wood and stone.

Advantages:

Various styles and low maintenance: Laminate cabinets come in a variety of colours, textures, and styles, providing flexibility in your choice. An added benefit is that they are easy to clean—a simple wipe with a damp cloth is all that's needed to make them look pristine.

Disadvantages:

Less authentic and not environmentally conscious: Regardless of its various styles and looks, this type of material does not give a natural look, making it a bit less aesthetically appealing compared to other wood materials. Also, the production process of this material requires chemicals and adhesives that are not eco-friendly, resulting in a material that is not biodegradable.

Ideal home:

Laminate kitchen cabinets are great for busy households thanks to their low maintenance and resistance to scratches and smudges. Homes that feature contemporary or modern designs will enjoy the wide range of colours and finishes that accompany laminate cabinets.

Pro tip:

Prioritising high-pressure laminate (HPL) for kitchen cabinets is crucial due to its superior durability and resistance to scratches, heat, and moisture. These characteristics ensure that HPL cabinets maintain their aesthetic appeal and structural integrity, even in the demanding environment of a kitchen.

Acrylic cabinets feature a high-gloss finish created by applying an acrylic sheet over a substrate such as MDF or particleboard. This material is known for its sleek, modern look.

Advantages:

Sleek modern look complemented with durability: This material provides a high-gloss kitchen that enhances its brightness and modern appeal. Furthermore, acrylic cabinets are resilient and can resist moisture, UV lighting, and scratches.

Disadvantages:

High price and complex installation: This type of material is generally more expensive than other kitchen cabinet materials. Additionally, installation requires precision, and improper installation can lead to visible seams and joints. Professional installation might be required, adding to the overall cost.

Ideal home:

Acrylic-style kitchen cabinets work well in contemporary and minimalist design schemes adding a bright, open atmosphere. Those who choose acrylic style cabinets will enjoy the low maintenance as they are resistant to moisture, UV lighting, and scratches providing long-lasting beauty and functionality.

Pro tip:

To ensure a seamless finish and avoid visible seams, consider professional installation, and select high-quality acrylic for enhanced durability and consistent colour. This will result in a more polished appearance and long-lasting kitchen cabinets that will maintain their aesthetic appeal over time.

Stone cabinets use natural stone slabs to create a unique, luxurious look. They are known for their resistance to heat and scratches. Common types include granite, marble, and quartz.

Advantages:

Enhance home value and low maintenance: Stone cabinets provide a high-end look and durability, as well as attractive features that add value to your home while enticing potential buyers. Their high durability makes them resistant to heat, scratches, UV, and moisture.

Disadvantages:

High cost and ongoing maintenance: This type of cabinet material is among the most expensive for kitchen cabinetry. Moreover, some stone materials, like marble and granite, require regular sealing, which adds to the cost and can be a hassle for homeowners.

Ideal home:

Stone style kitchen cabinets are for homes that embrace luxury and timeless aesthetics, featuring traditional design elements where unique stone elements can be displayed. This type of cabinet is suited for creating an elegant design in one’s kitchen.

Pro tip:

When choosing materials like granite or marble for your kitchen cabinets, be sure that your kitchen structure can support their substantial weight and be prepared for maintenance requirements such as periodic sealing. These steps will help maintain the durability and aesthetic appeal of these materials over time, preventing issues related to weight and preserving their pristine condition.

Stainless steel cabinets are commonly used in commercial kitchens due to their durability and ease of maintenance. They are also becoming popular in modern residential kitchens.

Advantages:

Hygenic with a modern aesthetic: Stainless steel cabinets are non-porous, meaning they do not harbour bacteria, mould, and other contaminants. In addition to their cleanliness, this material offers a sleek contemporary look, providing an industrial appeal to your kitchen.

Disadvantages:

Fingerprints and lighting: Fingerprints and smudges come on quite easily with this material, giving it a dirty look. Furthermore, stainless steel is a reflective material, which can cause unpleasant glares depending on the lighting in your home.

Ideal home:

Stainless steel kitchen cabinets create a modern and industrial look. You’ll find that this style is used in minimalist design schemes. Furthermore, this type of cabinet is perfect for busy households due to its durability and low maintenance.

Pro tip:

When selecting stainless steel kitchen cabinets, look for fingerprint-resistant finishes to reduce smudges and maintain a clean appearance. Finding stainless steel with this feature will minimise the need for frequent wiping, helping to keep the cabinets looking clean with less effort.

Lighting can dramatically affect the look of your kitchen cabinets. Stainless steel, for example, can enhance brightness and create a more open feel when combined with good lighting. Whereas a combination of warm-toned wood cabinets and soft lighting can make for a cosy atmosphere. Meanwhile, acrylic cabinets work well with brighter light, contributing to a sleek, contemporary look.

Related article: 13 types of light fixtures and how to use them

There’s a lot that goes into renovating your kitchen. Everything from flooring to lighting can be involved. However, when planning your budget, it's essential to allocate resources wisely, particularly for kitchen cabinets. As a general rule, allocate 40 per cent of your budget to kitchen cabinets, ensuring they are both aesthetically pleasing and functional. Furthermore, it’s better to prioritise long-term savings and durability over initial costs. While cheaper materials are great in the short run, this can lead to higher maintenance and repair costs. By allocating a proper budget with a focus on high-quality materials you’ll find yourself with an easy-to-take-care-of kitchen.

As you can see, there are many material options that can make ideal kitchen cabinets for your home. By understanding the benefits and drawbacks of each one you'll be able to make an informed decision. Whether it’s the calming effect of solid wood cabinets or the sleek industrial feel of stainless steel, you'll be able to find something that gives you the look and functionality you want and need.

Related article: 7 types of kitchen cabinet handles and how to use them best